An attorney involved in the high-profile U.S. Supreme Court case Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission has said that Justice Anthony Kennedy appeared to have accepted the arguments of Jack Phillips, a Christian baker who refused to make a cake for a same-sex wedding.
On Tuesday, the high court started hearing the oral arguments in the case over whether Phillips can be forced by the state of Colorado to design and create a cake celebrating same-sex marriage in violation of his religious beliefs.
Jonathan Scruggs, an attorney with the Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF), which is representing the Colorado baker, said he felt that the oral arguments "went well."
In an interview with The Christian Post, Scruggs said that the justices, including Kennedy, appeared to be "very open to many of our arguments."
"Kennedy seemed to really hit the nail on the head talking about the importance of tolerance being essential in a free society and tolerance is most meaningful when its mutual," the attorney recounted.
"It did not seem to him that the state was being tolerant of Mr. Phillips' religious beliefs. That is a pretty compelling statement," he added.
Kennedy, who is often a swing vote on controversial cases, stressed during the oral arguments that "tolerance is essential in a free society. And tolerance is most meaningful when it's mutual."
"It seems to me that the state in its position here has been neither tolerant nor respectful of Mr. Phillips' religious beliefs," the judge went on to say.
The Supreme Court is currently made up of five-leaning justices and four justices with more liberal inclinations.
During the oral arguments, Kennedy, a noted libertarian and the author of all the court's major gay-rights cases, expressed concern that a ruling in favor of Phillips might allow shop owners to put up signs saying, "We do not bake cakes for gay weddings."
While Kennedy had voted in favor of gay rights in the past, he had leaned towards gay rights in cases that do not pose a threat to first amendment rights.
In Boy Scouts of America v. Dale, a case which disputed whether the Scouts could prohibit homosexuals from serving as troop leaders, Kennedy sided with the Scouts because it is a private institution that has the right to discriminate on the basis of their policies.
Phillips' case is one of several court battles involving Christian professionals who cater to weddings (such as florists, photographers, and caterers).
Nearly 100 amicus briefs have been filed in relation to Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission, including one from the Trump administration, which filed a brief supporting Phillips.
- Medical waste company terminates contracts with abortion providers
- Pew survey reveals significant drop in Americans who believe Biblical nativity story
- University of Iowa sued for expelling Christian student group over leadership faith requirement
- Pentagon to begin enlistment of transgender recruits next month
Apart from attacks from Fulani herdsmen and Islamic extremist group Boko Haram, Christians in Nigeria are also facing increasing threats and attacks from occult groups that are targeting churches at night.
Many Americans who consider themselves evangelicals do not actually hold evangelical beliefs, survey finds
About a quarter of Americans consider themselves to be evangelical Christians, but a survey has found that a significant proportion does not actually hold evangelical beliefs.
A Christian teacher in the U.K. is suing a school after he was suspended for referring to a transgender pupil, who self-identifies as male, as a girl.
A prominent secularist group has called for an IRS investigation into an Alabama church after it displayed a sign that endorsed Republican Senate candidate Roy Moore.
A leading secularist group has raised concerns about cross memorials that were created by high school students in Georgia as part of a city effort to honor local military veterans.
The supporters of the Islamic State terror group are reportedly trying to frame Christians for the attack on Al Rawdah mosque in Egypt last month in an attempt to incite revenge attacks against them over the holiday season.
Members of the British parliament are asking the government to consider refusing entry to U.S. evangelist Franklin Graham, who is accused of making inflammatory comments against Islam and the LGBT community.
A new documentary from the History Channel has claimed that Jesus Christ may not have been born in a stable of an inn but a residential house owned by Joseph's relative in Bethlehem.
A young boy who was staying at the Smyllum Park orphanage in the 1960s was beaten "black and blue" after catching two nuns in an embrace at a boiler room, a child abuse inquiry has heard.
There has been a significant decline in President Donald Trump's job approval rating since February, and it is most noticeable among white evangelical Protestants, a group that proved to be his core voting bloc in the 2016 elections.
The European Parliament has reportedly threatened to impose sanctions against Poland if the country's lawmakers approve a church-backed legislation that would ban abortions on handicapped fetuses.